Column
media
column
Stainless steel, steel, and aluminum: How to choose screw materials according to their applications
Introduction
Screws are essential components used to fasten objects in both our daily lives and industrial settings. They come in a wide variety, and selecting the optimal material according to the intended application significantly impacts product quality and durability.
Among them, stainless steel, steel, and aluminum are the most commonly used screw materials. Each has unique properties and must be selected appropriately depending on the usage environment and purpose. In this article, we will explain in detail the characteristics, applications, and selection points of these screw materials.
Materials and Characteristics of Screws
Choosing the right screw material requires careful consideration of the usage environment and purpose. Below is an overview of three typical screw materials—stainless steel, steel, and aluminum—and their basic characteristics.
Stainless Steel Screws
Stainless steel screws are known for their excellent corrosion resistance, making them ideal for use in humid or outdoor environments. They also offer good strength and heat resistance, allowing them to be used in a wide range of applications.
Steel Screws
Steel screws are valued for their high strength and cost performance. They are widely used in construction and machinery where strength is essential. However, they are prone to rust, so surface treatments may be required depending on the environment.
Aluminum Screws
Aluminum screws are lightweight and corrosion-resistant, making them suitable for fields where weight reduction is important, such as in aerospace and electronic devices. Although they are not as strong as steel or stainless steel, they are highly recyclable.
Characteristics and Applications of Each Type of Screw
| Property | Stainless Steel Screws | Steel Screws | Aluminum Screws |
|---|---|---|---|
| Strength | High tensile strength and excellent durability. Types like SUS410 offer particularly high hardness. | Non-alloy steel has moderate strength, while carbon steel and alloy steel offer very high strength. | Lightweight but weaker than steel or stainless. Use aluminum alloys when higher strength is needed. |
| Corrosion Resistance | Outstanding corrosion resistance. SUS304 and SUS316 are highly rust-resistant, suitable for marine and chemical environments. | Low corrosion resistance, but can be improved with zinc or chrome plating. | High corrosion resistance; can be further enhanced with anodizing. |
| Heat Resistance | Excellent performance in high temperatures. SUS310S is especially heat-resistant and used in boilers and furnaces. | Moderate heat resistance. Special alloy steels are needed for high-temperature environments. | Low heat resistance, but some aluminum alloys can offer better performance. |
| Weight | Moderate. Lighter than steel but heavier than aluminum. | Heaviest among the three. | Extremely lightweight (about 1/3 the weight of steel). |
| Workability | Good workability, though it may gall under certain conditions. | Good machinability. Higher carbon content increases hardness but reduces machinability. | Soft and easy to machine but prone to galling and welding. |
| Cost | Expensive. High-corrosion-resistant types like SUS316 are especially costly. | Inexpensive. Mass-produced with excellent cost performance. | Moderate cost. Cost-effective when considering weight savings and recyclability. |
Stainless Steel Screws
Stainless steel screws are highly valued for their resistance to rust and their attractive luster. They are especially useful in locations where aesthetic appearance is important or in rust-prone environments like areas with water exposure.
Key Characteristics:
- Excellent corrosion resistance, heat resistance, and strength; difficult to rust
- SUS304 is optimal for general-purpose environments
- SUS316 has superior corrosion resistance and is used in marine or chemical plant environments
- SUS410 offers high strength and hardness
Applications:
- Outdoor facilities (bridges, buildings)
- Marine environments (ships, port facilities)
- Food processing machinery and medical devices (where hygiene is critical)
- Chemical plants
Advantages:
- High corrosion and heat resistance
- Easy maintenance and suitable for long-term use
- Attractive appearance
Disadvantages:
- High cost
- Prone to galling, especially under high torque
Recommended Use Cases for Stainless Steel Screws:
- In outdoor or wet environments where rusting is a concern
- In food or medical fields where hygiene is a priority
- When high strength is required
Steel Screws
Steel screws offer very high strength and, with various surface treatments, can be used in a wide range of environments.
Key Characteristics:
- Carbon steel has high strength and is commonly used in general applications
- Alloy steel offers even greater strength and is used in specialized environments
- Corrosion resistance can be improved with surface treatments
Applications:
- Construction and civil engineering (steel structures, bridges)
- Automotive parts (engines, suspension systems)
- General mechanical parts (industrial machinery, home appliances)
Advantages:
- Extremely high strength
- Inexpensive and easy to source
- Capable of a wide variety of surface treatments
Disadvantages:
- Prone to rust (surface treatment is required)
- Heavy weight
Improved Corrosion Resistance Through Surface Treatments:
- Zinc plating: Improves corrosion resistance in general environments
- Chrome plating: Provides higher corrosion resistance and a decorative appearance
- Parkerizing (phosphate coating): Enhances corrosion and wear resistance
Recommended Use Cases for Steel Screws:
- When high strength is required
- When cost needs to be minimized
- When surface treatments enable use in a wide range of environments
Aluminum Screws
Aluminum screws are lightweight yet highly corrosion-resistant, making them ideal for applications where weight reduction is crucial, such as in aircraft and electronic devices.
Key Characteristics:
- Lightweight and easy to handle
- Highly corrosion-resistant, with further improvement possible through anodizing
- Recyclable
Applications:
- Aircraft, automobiles, and railways (where weight reduction is critical)
- Electronic devices (smartphones, computers)
- Medical equipment (lightweight and non-magnetic requirements)
- Sporting goods
Advantages:
- Extremely lightweight
- High corrosion resistance
- Recyclable with low environmental impact
Disadvantages:
- Lower strength (unsuitable for high-load applications)
- Low heat resistance
- Prone to galling (cold welding)
Recommended Use Cases for Aluminum Screws:
- When weight reduction is a top priority
- When corrosion resistance is required
- In electronic devices or other applications requiring non-magnetic properties
Selection Points
When selecting screws, the choice of material is extremely important. This section provides a detailed explanation on how to choose screw materials from five perspectives: strength, corrosion resistance, weight reduction, heat resistance, and cost.
1. When Strength Is Required
Screw Selection in High-Load Environments:
In high-load environments, screws must withstand significant force. For example, in structural components of buildings or in power transmission parts of machinery, screws bear heavy loads. Choosing the wrong screw can lead to breakage or accidents, so careful selection is necessary.
Material Strength Comparison and Selection Criteria:
- Steel Screws: Very high strength, ideal for high-load applications. Strength varies by type, such as carbon or alloy steel.
- Stainless Steel Screws: Slightly lower in strength than steel, but offers corrosion resistance as well. Suitable where both strength and corrosion resistance are required.
- Aluminum Screws: Lower in strength compared to steel and stainless, but excellent for lightweight needs in low-load environments.
Selection Guidelines:
- Accurately estimate the load applied to the screw
- Consider the temperature and humidity of the environment
- Choose screws with adequate strength while factoring in a safety margin
2. When Corrosion Resistance Is Required
Types of Corrosive Environments and Material Selection:
Screws are used in a variety of environments, some of which are highly corrosive. For example, outdoor areas, locations with water exposure, and chemical plants can all lead to rust or corrosion. In such settings, corrosion resistance is a critical factor in screw selection.
Comparison of Corrosion Resistance by Material and Selection Guidelines:
- Stainless Steel Screws: Excellent corrosion resistance and rust prevention, ideal for corrosive environments. SUS304 and SUS316 offer varying levels of resistance.
- Aluminum Screws: Second only to stainless in corrosion resistance. Anodizing further enhances their durability.
- Steel Screws: Low natural resistance to corrosion but can be improved with surface treatments like plating.
Selection Guidelines:
- Accurately assess the corrosiveness of the environment
- Consider the types of substances the screw will come into contact with
- Choose screws with long-term corrosion resistance for extended use
3. When Weight Reduction Is Required
Benefits of Weight Reduction and Material Selection:
Reducing product weight offers numerous benefits, such as improved fuel efficiency and reduced transportation costs. Screws also contribute to overall product weight, so selecting lighter screw materials becomes important when weight reduction is a priority.
Weight Comparison of Materials and Selection Guidelines:
- Aluminum Screws: Extremely lightweight and ideal for weight-sensitive applications. They weigh about one-third of steel screws.
- Stainless Steel Screws: Heavier than aluminum, but lighter than steel. Suitable when balancing strength and weight reduction.
- Steel Screws: Heaviest among the three; not recommended where lightweight is essential.
Selection Guidelines:
- Consider the target weight of the entire product
- Take into account where the screws will be used and the required strength
- Evaluate whether additional cost for lighter materials is acceptable
4. When Heat Resistance Is Required
Choosing Screws for High-Temperature Environments:
In high-temperature environments, heat resistance becomes a crucial factor. For instance, around engines or inside high-heat machinery, screws may be exposed to elevated temperatures. If the screw material lacks adequate heat resistance, it may weaken or deform over time.
Material Comparison for Heat Resistance and Selection Guidelines:
- Stainless Steel Screws: Excellent resistance to high temperatures. SUS310S in particular offers superior performance in heat-intensive settings.
- Steel Screws: Moderate heat resistance, but can be used in high-temperature environments when made from special alloy steels.
- Aluminum Screws: Generally low heat resistance, though certain aluminum alloys can provide improved performance.
Selection Guidelines:
- Accurately determine the maximum temperature in the usage environment
- Choose screws that maintain strength under elevated temperatures
- Consider long-term use and anticipate changes in heat resistance over time
5. Cost
Selecting Screw Materials According to Budget:
Screw costs vary significantly depending on the type and quantity of material used. Selecting appropriate screw materials within budget constraints is important for managing the overall cost of a product.
Material Cost Comparison and Long-Term Cost Performance:
- Steel Screws: Generally the most affordable, making them suitable when cost reduction is a priority.
- Aluminum Screws: More expensive than steel, but may offer better cost performance considering weight reduction and recyclability.
- Stainless Steel Screws: The most expensive option, but their superior corrosion and durability performance can make them cost-effective in the long term.
Selection Guidelines:
- Consider the total budget for the product
- Factor in the quantity and required strength of screws
- Account for long-term maintenance and replacement costs
Summary
Selecting the right screws is a key factor that influences the performance and durability of a product. By choosing the optimal material based on environment and purpose, you can ensure long-term reliability and improve cost efficiency. We hope this article helps you make better decisions when selecting screws.
Conclusion
For inquiries regarding samples or materials, please respond to this email or contact our sales representative!
At Ohta Vietnam, we not only provide ready-made products such as screws and bolts, but also support activities in the manufacturing field such as cutting, inspection, assembly, packaging…
Our equipment list is here
As a “specialized support” for the manufacturing industry in Asia. If you have any related questions, feel free to contact Ohta Vietnam for detailed support!
URL: https://ohtavn.com/en/contact/